Inter Law – Whiplash controversy in medical academia as opinions are divided

Because the biological sciences behind whiplash injuries are presently unknown and because injuries are often not apparent but instead involve ‘invisible’ damage a lot of medical investigations and articles have been written on the subject. Some academics believe that whiplash is more of a social problem than a medical one, claiming that those injured are encouraged to exaggerate their pain, take out legal action and request medical help which they may not necessarily need.

It was in The Journal of the American Medical Association over half a century ago that Gay and Abbot first described a common injury to the neck which they called whiplash. Since that article was published, all the way back in 1953, whiplash incidence in the western world has risen to pandemic proportions.

In 75% of patients whiplash symptoms last more than 6 months and symptoms don’t commonly present until weeks or months after the accident takes place. On average whiplash sufferers lose approximately 8 weeks of work time and the injury is 5 times more common in women than it is in men.

Michael Livingstone MA MD refers to whiplash as a ‘modern epidemic’. In the Journal of The Royal Society of Medicine he wrote: “Despite attention from a profusion of physicians, paramedicals, pain clinics and conferences [whiplash] remains an enigma.” He posits that many of the authors who write about whiplash do not describe the injury in a clear and detailed way. Livingstone says that Gay and Abbott, the first people to write about whiplash were also guilty of this. He adds in his paper that other medical authors usually fail to offer definitions and that definitions from expert to expert widely vary.

Livingstone said that the first step to combating the high incidence rate of whiplash was a mechanical one. He proposed better car seat designs and technological approaches to reducing injury. Livingstone also said that a number of steps could be taken by the medical community to reduce whiplash in the future and that the medical authorities must “Define whiplash injury more clearly”. Medical training, he suggested must be improved and pre-accident symptoms of patients should be taken into account. He added that health care professionals should resist over-treatment, reward patients for ‘becoming well’ rather than remaining ill, reduce the influence of attorneys and especially discourage symptom diaries.

He said that healthcare professionals must examine their own effectiveness, learn from parallels, reduce research bias, communicate better with each other and finally that society must offer greater incentives to accident free drivers.

In a different article which he wrote for the British Columbia Medical Association Livingstone said: “… whiplash injury was described frequently in the American literature after 1953, but not described among British patients in the UK major journals for the next 30 years. Normally a new syndrome described on one side of the Atlantic surfaces on the other side within 3 years. In whiplash injury it did not.

He asks: “Why did British patients, particularly in traffic-dense London, not complain of whiplash symptoms sufficiently to draw researchers’ attention? Why had no researcher commented on the difference between the two countries?” Many academics believe that whiplash is more of a social problem than a medical one and an amount of cynicism towards the illness perhaps unfairly exists. But, until a detailed definition of the injury is agreed upon and the ailment is better understood by doctors everywhere the controversy surrounding the issue will continue to divide opinions in the medical community.

Related Articles

whiplash claims
Claiming for Whiplash compensation Car accidents happen everyday leaving many non fault victims with severe injuries, the most common……Read More

whiplash claims
Making whiplash injury claims Whiplash is the most common type of injury people suffer after a car accident. The……Read More

whiplash compensation claims
Steps to getting whiplash compensation Making whiplash compensation claims for a car accident is quick and simple. Call our……Read More

Related News

20/02/2017 10:38:21
Playing the Level Field Yorkshire Police Crack Down on Uninsured Drivers
Playing the Level Field: Yorkshire Police Crack Down on Uninsured Drivers Being involved in a car accident can has to top the list of the most bothersome events to befall……Read More

Little Lydia wins compensation battle
A brave young girl who had to have both her legs amputated after her GP failed to make a house call is to receive a six-figure compensation payout.London’s High Court……Read More

Survey: Ambulances pose a super-bug risk
Super-bug MRSA can be spread by dirty ambulances – with slack sanitation procedures opening the way to future outbreaks and medical negligence compensation claims. This is the assertion of trade……Read More

57)) event.returnValue = false;}function onlyAlphabetic(){//if ((event.keyCode < 48) || (event.keyCode > 57)) event.returnValue = true;if ((event.keyCode == 32) || (event.keyCode>64 && event.keyCode96 && event.keyCode 57)) || (event.keyCode == 32)) event.returnValue = true;//else event.returnValue = false;if ((event.keyCode < 48) || (event.keyCode > 57)) event.returnValue = false;}]]>
        Simply fill in the brief form below and one of our specialist claims advisors will be in contact with you very shortly. Name:
Accident Type: Please SelectRoad AccidentWork AccidentMedical NegligencePublic Liabilitytrip/SlipOther

Our solicitors are accredited by the Law Society

Minor injuries and whiplash for couple after car catches fire
A couple, who survived what could have been a fatal accident when their car caught fire, were taken to hospital……Read More

Liverpool academy player critically ill after car accident
A talented young footballer is critically ill in hospital after a car crash that claimed the lives of two of……Read More

Highways Agency to announce M25 contract victors
The Highways Agency will make a decision this week as to which of three major consortiums should be awarded the……Read More

Click Here To Read More News

RSS Feed

Inter Law is not regulated by the Department for Constitutional Affairs in respect of regulated claims management activities. We have no authorisation number and our registration is not recorded on the Department for Constitutional Affairs website

*Charges may be applicable in exceptional circumstances About Us :: Sitemap :: Contact Us :: Disclaimer :: Privacy Policy
Accident Claims :: Injury Lawyers :: Compensation Claims :: No Win No Fee* :: Personal Injury Claims :: Whiplash Injury Claims
Work Accident Claims :: Medical Negligence Claims

© 2017 INTER Solicitors All Rights Reserved